AN INDEPENDENT LEGAL AFFAIRS PUBLICATIONEDITION · 29 October 2026RSS
Business & Human Rights in LawBHRINLAW.ORG

Corporate accountability.
Human rights. Courts & enforcement.

EXPLAINER / France

France’s vigilance law separates injunctions from damages claims

France’s duty-of-vigilance statute creates two distinct civil routes: a court may order a company to comply with plan duties, while a damages claim depends on ordinary liability rules and a direct causal link. The Constitutional Council also narrowed who may bring that claim and struck down a separate punitive fine.

One statute, two different questions

France’s duty-of-vigilance law is often described as one accountability mechanism, but its Commercial Code provisions ask two different questions. The current Article L. 225-102-1 concerns whether a covered company has established and effectively implemented a vigilance plan. Article L. 225-102-2 concerns whether a failure to meet those duties caused damage that civil-liability law requires the company to repair. Those numbers took effect on 1 January 2025; the 2017 Constitutional Council decision and many earlier accounts use the former numbers, L. 225-102-4 and L. 225-102-5. Keeping the numbering change visible helps avoid confusing a historical citation with the current code. The current plan provision, the current liability provision, and the Constitutional Council’s 2017 decision document the distinction.

The planning duty applies to companies meeting employee thresholds over two consecutive year ends: at least 5,000 employees in the company and French subsidiaries, or at least 10,000 across the company and French and foreign subsidiaries. The statutory plan addresses serious human-rights, fundamental-freedoms, health-and-safety, and environmental risks linked to the company, controlled entities, and certain established commercial relationships with subcontractors and suppliers. Its required components include risk mapping, regular assessments, prevention or mitigation measures, an alert mechanism, and monitoring of effectiveness. These are statutory duties for companies within scope, not a general obligation imposed on every business. Article L. 225-102-1 contains the thresholds and plan elements.

The injunction route focuses on compliance

The first route is preventive and directed at the plan duty itself. Under Article L. 225-102-1, a person with an interest to act may seek an order requiring compliance after the company has been formally put on notice and has failed to comply within three months. The court may attach a periodic financial penalty to the injunction. The provision also allows the president of the court to be asked for relief in référé, France’s interim-proceedings procedure. This route does not, by itself, establish that a particular person suffered compensable injury. The statute states the notice condition, three-month period and possible injunction; the Constitutional Council’s decision records that the order mechanism remained constitutional.

A damages claim needs injury and causation

The second route is a civil-liability claim. Article L. 225-102-2 refers to Articles 1240 and 1241 of the Civil Code and links a breach of vigilance obligations to repair of harm that the required performance would have prevented. The Constitutional Council explained in 2017 that this reference invokes ordinary French liability rules; the company is not automatically responsible for every harm caused by a subsidiary or supplier. The Council said a direct causal link between the company’s own failure and the damage must be established. The statutory rule, Civil Code Article 1240, and paragraphs 24–29 of the Council’s decision support that distinction.

The same decision limits standing. Although the statutory wording refers to a person with an interest to act, the Council held that the rule does not let an outside party sue on behalf of the victim; the victim is the person with the relevant interest. It also confirmed that the liability provision can apply, where its conditions are met, to damage occurring abroad. That does not make all overseas harm attributable to a French parent: the claim still turns on the company’s own breach and the required causal connection. The Council’s decision explains both points, while the Commercial Code provision states the liability and standing language.

What the 2017 constitutional ruling removed

The Constitutional Council did not invalidate the vigilance plan or the two civil routes. It struck down a separate provision that would have allowed a civil fine of up to €10 million for a failure to meet the plan obligations, reasoning that the legislature had not defined the punishable breach with enough precision. The remaining injunction and damages provisions were upheld, with the damages rule understood through ordinary civil liability and the Council’s interpretation of standing. It is therefore inaccurate to describe the ruling as either a complete rejection of the law or as leaving that proposed fine in force. The decision’s reasoning and operative ruling distinguish the removed fine from the surviving provisions.

In practical legal reporting, the status of a proceeding should follow the remedy actually sought and the court’s decision. An order requiring a plan to be prepared or corrected is a compliance outcome; a damages judgment requires a separate finding of injury and causation; an appeal may leave either result under review. The statutory design supplies categories for analyzing those outcomes, but no article can determine whether an individual company’s plan complies or whether a particular claimant can prove a case.